:quality(88))
Sales for Introverts Who Run an Agency or Consulting Firm
By Kurt Schmidt
|November 17, 2026
I'm Kurt Schmidt of Schmidt Consulting Group, and I'm an introvert who finds himself in sales situations a lot. People hate being sold, so I'm always providing valuable information and treating people as colleagues and as peers. The majority of my work comes in through referrals, and those referrals come from the podcast, the networking, the YouTube channel, LinkedIn, and workshops.
As the president of my company, I find myself in sales situations a lot.
I'm an introvert too, but you can't let introversion get in the way of your goals.
The work should speak for itself. It does, but only if people are looking at it. And it can be fun. When you're doing it right, it feels like just a natural part of the business.
Key Takeaways
- Putting on your sales hat doesn't change who you are, because it's a means to an end.
- I want to get the conversation off of me as quickly as possible and onto the other person.
- Commenting on other people's stuff is more powerful than posting yourself.
- My work comes in through referrals, and those referrals come from staying useful and consistent.
Is being an introvert a problem when you sell for your firm?
A lot of software developers who are starting agencies are very introverted people who don't like to get out and don't like to wave and say, hey, look at me. And it's okay.
I used to hate going to networking events, and these days I get really excited about going.
You will enjoy doing this stuff, maybe not at first, when it'll feel a little bit like work, but once I got better at it and started the conversations, I was like, I'm learning a lot.
Just because we're putting on our sales hat, or bonnet depending on the time of year, doesn't change us from being that person. It's a means to an end.
What does selling look like when you don't want to pitch?
People hate being sold, which is why we're always providing valuable information and treating people as colleagues and as peers.
The messages we send people on LinkedIn are invitations to celebrate them. When I reach out, I ask, "Hey, how can I get you some free information?" It's super simple.
I set up honey for a very specific type of bee. I keep it very nice and consistent, and the right people keep arriving. But every once in a while, I have to go out and let people know that this thing is there. We want to invite people to a party.
When you do talk about your firm, tell them what you did. We have to speak in outcomes.
How do you run a sales conversation as an introvert?
When you meet, start with what you're looking for and why you're there. If you tell them right out of the gate who you're looking to meet, you both become immediately more comfortable. And that person immediately knows whether or not they can help you.
Then the goal is to get it off of me as quickly as possible and onto them. I always want to play hot potato with the conversation.
Just listen to where they go first, because a lot of the time what I like to do is just shut up, and if you've known me for any amount of time, you can see how difficult it is for me to do that.
I used to just keep talking and keep selling. It took me a long time to learn to let the presentation do its work. Ask, "What are your thoughts?" Then wait until they actually say some thoughts.
The best question I've learned to ask is, why is now the time to do this? I cannot tell you how many deals I've won in the past fifteen years by clients saying, well, you ask the questions other firms skipped.
While I'm waiting to hear back, I might see something they shared on social media and reach out: "Hey, I saw that thing you shared." Then I leave it at that. I treat them like a person.
Which small habits bring in work without charisma?
The way you need to think about LinkedIn is that it's like a business conference that's going on twenty-four seven. Just like at a business conference, we want to spend time with people that we like.
Commenting on people's posts is what's key. I can't tell you how many direct messages those comments have opened up for me. Commenting on other people's stuff is more powerful than posting yourself.
Being seen matters more than asking hard. In Hinge and XPX's Report on Referrals Research, 262 people who give referrals, mostly business advisors, were asked for the top three things that decrease the chance of referring someone, and "absence of visible expertise" led the list at 45.5 percent of picks. "Not asking for referrals" was 1.1 percent.
My advice on connection requests is to send out three or four a day, which takes you 15 minutes.
Follow up with people. If you don't hear from them, follow up a third time and say, okay, this is the last time, I don't want to bother you. People get busy.
What happens with small firms is that you get busy with the work, and you figure you don't need to worry about new clients as much. That's why you've got to build a system that keeps you consistent.
We can manufacture luck by creating lots of opportunity at networking events and by posting and commenting to stay visible. Consistency builds up timing. When opportunity and timing meet, that is a project or a retainer.
To see whether the habits are working, watch a few agency numbers.
Where does the work come from if you don't cold pitch?
The majority of my work comes in through referrals. Those referrals come from all this stuff I do: the podcast, the networking, the YouTube channel, LinkedIn, and a lot of workshops.
Past clients are where agency referrals start. In SparkToro and Paddy Moogan's State of Digital Agencies 2024, 66 percent of 612 agency owners and consultants said their top source of referrals for new business was existing and past clients. Partner companies came second at nearly 13 percent.
What's more important to me than selling directly on LinkedIn is getting referrals from people on LinkedIn. The most profitable side of LinkedIn for me is going out, trying to provide value, and somebody saying, hey, that's a person who provides value.
I've had so many clients over the years contact me and say, I love your stuff on LinkedIn, I want to meet you. These are people who have never commented.
My dad always taught me that when the invitations dry up, you throw your own parties.
When I have something new to offer, I go to people I trust who maybe could buy it and ask them to put on their buyer's hat and tell me what they think.
If you'd rather stop being the one who sells, here's how an owner hands off the selling, and if you're asking whether to hire, read when to hire your first salesperson.
How does Schmidt Consulting Group help an introverted firm owner bring in work?
Schmidt Consulting Group works with founder-led agencies and professional services firms on positioning, pricing, and new business.
Mentorship is twice-monthly counsel for founders on pricing, hiring, clients, and direction. You set the agenda, and your team does the work.
Advisory is a weekly operating rhythm for growth: a written plan, one priority at a time, and a review of results every week.
A two-founder production studio worked with us twice a month, and the list of companies built in those sessions got them a meeting with Google.
If you want outside help with the selling itself, here's what sales coaching for agency owners should fix. You'll hear the fee on our first call.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an introvert sell for an agency or consulting firm?
Yes, and I'm an introvert who sells for my firm all the time. You can't let introversion get in the way of your goals.
How do you sell without feeling like a salesperson?
People hate being sold, so I give them free information and treat them as colleagues and peers. When we meet, I tell them who I'm looking to meet and why I'm there, and then I play hot potato and get the conversation off of me and onto them as quickly as possible. I ask why now is the time to do this, and then I wait for their thoughts. Clients have told me I ask the questions other firms skipped.
Does networking work for an introvert?
I used to hate networking events, and I look forward to them these days. Opening with who you're looking to meet makes both of you more comfortable.
Can an owner who dislikes selling still get referrals?
Most of my work arrives as referrals, and I get them by providing value where people can see it. Plenty of people who contacted me had never once commented on my posts. A steady system matters, because when you get busy with client work, new business is the first thing to slide.
Who helps an agency owner who dislikes selling?
At Schmidt Consulting Group, founders who don't love selling can work with me through Mentorship, which meets twice a month, or Advisory, which runs on a weekly plan and review. I'll share the fee on our first call.
About Kurt Schmidt
Kurt Schmidt is an agency growth consultant, host of The Road Map with Kurt Schmidt podcast, author of The Attraction Agency, and co-founder of a fifty-person agency that made the Inc. 5000 twice. He helps agency founders build sales and marketing systems.
More about Kurt →
Related Articles
How to Grow a Management Consulting Firm Past Your Network
How a consulting firm with a team finds clients beyond the founder's network: what to fix first, what to add, and what to skip.
Sales Coaching for Agency Owners: What It Should Fix
Sales coaching for agency owners should fix how you sell before it trains the seller: discovery, the proposal, the price and the weekly pipeline review.
Agency Positioning Statements That Hold Up on Sales Calls