Skip to content
Schmidt ConsultingBook a Call
An agency owner at a home desk sorts a stack of printed inquiries into two piles beside a laptop and a coffee mug.

How to Get Bigger Clients for an Agency

By Kurt Schmidt

|

November 19, 2026

I'm Kurt Schmidt of Schmidt Consulting Group, and at the agency I ran, our first clients were whoever came in, until we got bigger and needed bigger clients. The more you can niche down who you're trying to attract, the easier it is to find them. You always will have two people to sell to, the people who use what you do and the people who sign off on it, and your best leads are going to come from people who know you.

When we first started at the agency I ran, we worked a lot with startups, because we were nimble, we were cheap, and it was easy to do. At first, it was kind of like whoever came along.

Then, as we got bigger, we needed to get bigger clients. You couldn't rely on whatever came in.

The projects you need once you've grown are probably a lot larger. They require a lot more trust and a lot more due diligence on the client's part.

Key Takeaways

  • The more you can niche down who you're trying to attract, the easier it is to find them.
  • You always will have two people to sell to: the people who use what you do and the people who sign off on it.
  • A case study from a different kind of buyer doesn't translate.
  • Your best leads are going to come from people who know you.

What are your small leads telling you?

Start by sorting your last inquiries by company size and by where they came from. Tracking where your wins come from is covered in agency KPIs.

When we tried outbound at the agency I ran, I didn't have an ideal client profile defined. I was like, well, we work with lots of different people. The people running it were like, cool, we'll send emails to lots of different people. My positioning was pretty bad at the beginning, and that's why none of that stuff worked as well.

If you just go out and say, I'm an agency that produces products for electronics companies, buyers don't know when to call you. The more you can niche down who you're trying to attract, the easier it is to find them and then get their attention.

Buyers want to know what's different about working with you. Otherwise, they're going to assume you're just like every other place and you work the same. Then you cost the same as every other place, or less, and you're just competing on price.

If you're weighing a change in your positioning, here's how to reposition an established agency without losing current business.

Who are you talking to at a larger buyer?

You always will have two people you need to sell to. You have the people who are actually going to use the stuff you're doing, and the people who sign off on it. They both need to be bought in.

Figure out the title of the people who buy from you versus the title of the people who use what you deliver. Then figure out where those people hang out.

Some agencies sell to decision makers just fine, and then all of a sudden they hit a ceiling. The reason is that they're strangers to everyone else in the stakeholder group. You're leaving it to the decision maker to be your salesperson inside the organization, and it falls flat every time. You've got to have a system in place that goes after influencers as much as it goes after decision makers.

You've got to have the person who signs the contract be a part of the conversation. Can't we get them involved earlier than when we're just sending over a proposal, and our contact is forwarding it to them saying, here's what I want to buy, can you sign off on this?

What proof do larger buyers need?

The case study has to come from the same kind of buyer. You go to a buyer and say, hey, look at the work we're doing with a client just like you. Don't you want to work with us?

It's smart to start with people you can get in front of. They're easier to convince because they'll trust you more. But you need those case studies, because they work like a stepping stone, and then it's easier to start bridging out to people who are harder to get in front of.

We're in a trust recession. As a buyer, I've got to see other people voting on this thing before I know what to vote on. People want low risk, high trust. They're buying outcomes.

The people who send you work need to see your expertise as well. In a Hinge Research Institute and XPX study of 262 advisors who give referrals, "Absence of Visible Expertise" was the top thing stopping them from referring a firm, at 45.5 percent. "Not Asking for Referrals" was 1.1 percent.

Where do bigger buyers come from?

Your best leads are going to come from people who know you, and the people who are actually going to pay you what you're worth are going to come from people who know you. In SparkToro and Paddy Moogan's 2024 survey of 612 agency owners and consultants, 66 percent said their top source of referrals was existing and past clients, and partner companies came second at nearly 13 percent.

I get most of my best referrals through people who are already working with a potential client in some capacity, or have worked with them, when that client needs something different from what they offer. Once I got a few partnerships pushing people in, the clients were just much bigger. They came in more hot, and they were more ready to go.

Outreach is kind of like watering your lawn. You just keep it running, but most of the bigger deals are going to come from other means. If you've mostly relied on outbound, The Attraction Agency Model covers the alternative to chasing.

You've got to go where they are at.

At the agency I ran, we wanted to start working with bigger enterprise companies, but we had worked mostly with mid-sized companies. We didn't have a lot of network into those groups. I hosted a panel event and reached out to the heads of marketing at these places: I'm doing a panel event, and I would love for you to be a guest speaker.

I made it look very professional, with the agenda and the time of the event, and I told them I'm not asking anything of you. And it worked. Those people came and did the event. Afterward, they were hanging out, and they were like, so what do you guys do here? I was like, let me show you.

You're never as important as you are when you host the party.

Could your agency handle a bigger client if one landed?

You've got this small regional airport, and you're like, I want to land 747s here. And I'm like, well, first we've got to look at the runways and the terminals. Could you even handle them if they landed?

You've got a lead gen problem, and then you've got a sales problem.

When a buyer says we have this business problem, it's your job to figure out how much the problem is costing them and how much they're willing to invest to solve it. We don't ask them what their budget is, because they haven't budgeted for it. If they ask for the rate early, we shut it down as fast as possible. Let's get clear on what this is costing you first, then we can scope the right fix and price against that.

You used to sell services like a waiter coming over with a menu, asking what you'd like. Agencies that are doing well today are order makers. People want tangible results, so your website has to be tailored towards outcomes.

You're always trying to upgrade your class of clients. That's your goal. Sometimes I cut my rate low because I want a testimonial from this person. At the agency I ran, we also let some clients go to make that move, handed them to another agency for a finder's fee, and bet our profit that we'd make more money without them.

How does Schmidt Consulting Group help an agency owner get bigger clients?

Schmidt Consulting Group works with founder-led agencies and professional services firms on positioning, pricing, and new business.

Mentorship is twice-monthly counsel for founders on pricing, hiring, clients, and direction. You set the agenda, and your team does the work.

Advisory is a weekly operating rhythm for growth: a written plan, one priority at a time, and a review of results every week.

You'll hear the fee on our first call.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are my agency's leads all small companies?

Often the buyers you want don't know when to buy from you, and they don't know what you do. They hired you for one thing. I watched teams pour endless energy into cold tactics while the opportunities were already forming around the work they were doing. That approach often leads to low-value projects and hesitant clients.

How do I attract bigger clients without changing what my agency does?

We change our positioning, and the business model stays the same. When we go to market, we're targeting very specific people with a very specific solution. Just because you say you work with fintech companies does not mean that you're only going to attract fintech companies. You get good in one space, and people in adjacent industries see it and want you to work in their space.

What do larger buyers want to see before they hire an agency?

I've seen agencies with less talent win bigger deals simply because they understood how trust works. A larger buyer wants proof from a client like them, so turn finished projects into proof that attracts the next client. A firm I worked with ran a weekly webinar that most of its biggest clients never attended, and the consistency alone told those clients it was a trustworthy source.

Do referrals and partners bring bigger clients than cold outreach?

In my own business, yes. Once a few partnerships started pushing people in, the size of the invoices I was shipping went up by a huge amount. When leads come in warm, conversations feel different, and you're deciding whether the fit is right.

Who helps an agency owner land bigger clients?

Kurt Schmidt and Schmidt Consulting Group help founder-led agencies and professional services firms with positioning, pricing, and new business. Mentorship meets twice a month with the founder setting the agenda, and Advisory runs weekly with a written plan, one priority at a time, and a results review. The fee comes up on the first call.

About Kurt Schmidt

Kurt Schmidt is an agency growth consultant, host of The Road Map with Kurt Schmidt podcast, author of The Attraction Agency, and co-founder of a fifty-person agency that made the Inc. 5000 twice. He helps agency founders build sales and marketing systems.

More about Kurt →

Related Articles